There have been a lot of problems within the Pirate Party that exists in the United States. I have been the administration officer at a time where there are more vacancies in officer seats than officers. A vote of no confidence was called, questioning my suitability on the day of my election, though no vote on the matter happened then and was dropped as a frivolous and personal attack. I have received neither email or even ideas from most of the Pirate Party members who take control of meetings, and have been outright berated for performing tasks that would be applauded in any other volunteer. It is apparent to me that the existing membership of the Pirate Party is not what I thought it was, in number and in focus. I feel that no coworkers exist within this group. There is an insular and vocal minority that seems to be dictating the tone of the party, a tone I do not agree with. There was a dubious vote to remove me from office once again. This reoccurs most times any party gatherings take place. This vote was not done appropriately and doesn't even meet the constitutionally mandated requirements such as requiring 3 sessions. I have contested these allegations in the past, however, this time I have decided to go along with it. I will be stepping down from my office and over the next few weeks, handing over the relevant logins and passwords I have in my possession.
As I spend the time to draft the documents and try to prepare the next volunteer or committee that will take over the responsibilities I currently have, I reflect a bit on the last 5 months and what I have learned. I feel the concern that the Pirate Party doesn't have an concrete identity is somewhat justified now. I assumed the Free Culture Movement was a social part of the Pirate movement. I assumed also that the DIY culture was an important group for the party, and I considered these metacommunities to be a part of the overall Pirate identity. It is now obvious to me that here, at least, this is not so much the case.
A piece of the pirate identity that I feel is of some contention is the real application of the 'remix culture' that, for now, is in early ‘alpha stages’. One example of this is the makerspace movement. I see elements of coops, corporate workspaces, independent contractor relationships, and DIY cultural aspects being mixed together in ways that vindicate some of the Free Culture movements stances on creative community. Additionally, I see this in the geocentric regional Burning Man communities, which seem to have penchants for all sorts of themed lifestyles, even if made somewhat easily available to the cultureless tourist. These things are not only interesting examples but are possible recruitment grounds for Pirates who may or may not already be interested in involvement in municipal politics. I cannot fathom how the possibility of such a relationship being beneficial escapes any individual. If these types of groups are not our constituency, then I've been under some very serious misconceptions. I will note that I chose those examples because they are communities that I have approached officially, spoke with, and was met with resistance from party members. I know that I'm not alone in some of these assumptions, as approaching the makerspace community was an idea born from this list. It is hard to know what the 'majority' of us think, today.
The current situation is as bleak as the one I came into initially. I am passing my information over to someone who wanted to be the promotions officer, who is, in turn, not sure they are going to be holding the administrator office position in a month. Spending a lot of time trying to walk him through the emails and logins and ongoing discussions might very well be in vain. The party will undergo, here, another complete reset, most likely as everyone scrambles at the disjointed pieces. There isn’t even a concrete single method to communicate with all membership today, so it remains impossible to gauge action or even guess at will. Right before I got involved, this reset appears to have happened as well, leaving us with 2 'official' groups (the US Pirate Party and the Pirate Party of the US) registered with a huge legal morass, implied by just ‘moving’ to the new legal title and IRS entry and transferring funds and assets over. I will do everything in my power (involving a lot of typing, I assume) to create a log of what the admin needs to know, and hopefully things will move ahead quickly. On that note, I admit I am deeply concerned for the future of the Pirate Party.
I am relieved, frankly, that soon, I shall no longer be the single most important topic to the entire Pirate Party US / US Pirate Party. The Pirate Party brand was on the front page of the Wall Street Journal just days ago. Because all the internal struggles that the US Pirate Party US party has been dealing with, we have been unable to use this to our advantage at all, and I find THAT to be a shame. I will continue doing the volunteer work that I have been. I need not be an official officer to start a podcast, promote ACTA awareness, try to find people who might run for office, and so on. So, now, it is likely I will move to more of a content creator role for the next few months.
I must add that I am touched at the sheer number of people who have contacted me to inform me that they support my actions and my efforts and hope to work productively together in the future. I can't think of much more I could ever ask for than that.
If you are in the US and are reading this, I would implore you to please become active in the party. It needs your help. It currently has no leadership. This is certainly both the time and the place in our world for the Pirate Party movement, and I eagerly anticipate what happens next. Moving forward, I hope to work with many of you, and I know I shall see you again soon.
Your position as "Administrator"
resulted in basically a road trip where you got some.
When doing a cross-country promotion, even my friends punk bands make sure there's a purpose and venues booked!
Name one thing that was accomplished during this pilgrimmage. You got good committed people here waiting for you to give them the nod to go forward and all you do is go on and on about how busy you are and thats why you can't get back to people. I personally have been sitting here waiting for you to tell me anything you need done that I can help with, but i'm guessing the reason I can't help with anything is because you aren't doing anything at all.
Do you know the proper format to issue a Press Release so it gets to the news organizations for exposure? Have you made any concrete contacts within the community you say you're "helping" so we can follow up and offer assisstance? No. Why? Because apparently you have it all covered and we all don't have to worry about it.
Not buying it.
A report in full on what has been accomplished would be appreciated seeing as you have an awful lot of time to respond via a diary entry on this blog when it involves your position but no time to talk to any of us.
Also, psychologically speaking, coming to the conclusion that everyone is a "jackass" and then going off to form your own party within a party is tell-tale signs of an egomaniacal and sociopathic individual.......your majesty.
California Contact
Anyone know the contact for a California rep of the party? Really anyone will do--I just want to see if the Pirates have begun registering signatures to get on some sort of ballot. I think if we made it to that point, there are at least enough college-aged youth to sign up as a joke and justify some sort of statewide conference, voting forum, etc. I'm thinking like a live-feed Twitter assembly or somesuch, with bills proposed and voted on by the body politic.
IRC
I've been active for about two contiguous weeks now, and have never been able to talk to you. I didn't know what your twitter or facebook accounts were until today. Much of this trauma could be avoided if people just talked! You should log onto IRC tonight.
talk to each other
I've also been able to communicate with Ryan as needed since about two weeks ago when he says he had his laptop fixed.
Furthermore the IRC server is no longer on freenode, it's on a third party server and is not publicized very well. I wasn't aware that IRC was the best medium for decision making anyway, but whatever ...
Additionally I was only recently made aware that Jan 12th was the last meeting, I would have liked to attend it if it was made more available to people - the only meeting notice I saw was the Jan 26th meeting - Kind of bogus if you are trying to say that out of seven or eight people attending meetings with 1 or no officers present that you have any sort of 'quorom' at all in determining the future of the Party.
The body of individuals currently referred to by Andrew as 'active' members is certainly not representative of all people who identify themselves as Pirates - in fact, it seems that certain individuals are doing all they can to ostracize and excommunicate those that aren't bowing themselves down to their self-appointed positions of power. I know a lot of people who have left
So yes, owen, there does need to be more communication between various factions of the pirate movement in the US - but it can only happen if everyone speaking is on equal standing - which means that some egos got to let go and let other people step up to the plate.
I've been Present the entire
I've been Present the entire time, and I assure you, Communication is not the issue. Andrew Norton and his Cronies are the issue. If he had been Banned the moment he began his Downpour of stupid bull**** this would not have happened.
Not the Actions of a Single Person
I am amazed at the attempts to lay the blame on Mr. Norton. He is made out to be the ringleader or the person that is solely responsible for the votes.
The votes were taken and the decisions were made by the majority of the members, not by Mr. Andrew. We have been called the "vocal minority" as an attempt to undermine our decision. If there is a majority that supported Mr. Ryan, silent or otherwise, then I would wonder why he has not been able to have them participate and voice their support.
The logs of the meetings are available on this site, and I encourage everyone that has questions about what has happened to read through the logs and form your own opinion.
meetings
DUSA, the meetings weren't exactly publicized very well - had I known about them I would have been there to voice my disapproval of Andrew's attempts to push forward votes of no confidence and so forth. Ryan has taken a really excessive amount of heat compared to every previous administrator of the party and it's not because of what he has or hasn't done, but because of the attempts of a few people to sway everybody against him. It's really disgusting and makes me ashamed to be a part of such a reactionary movement. I know people who have left the party because of Andrew's actions. Maybe you should wonder why the 'majority' of the members number in the seven-or-eight people in IRC and think whether that is truly representative of the pirate movement in the US.
What other avenue?
What other means of communication do we have other than the IRC? And even the link to the IRC has been disabled, so new members don't exactly have an easy way to reach it!
You cannot make any announcements on this site, every post has to be approved by Ryan or Bethany. And he made it clear that handing over those passwords to the Temp-Admin will take weeks. I submitted an editorial after the Christmas Day bombing, but no response from Ryan if he will post it or not.
There is no mailing list, the Facebook group has a lot of members but is essentially dead. We have a site that does not allow the posting of new information, the only thing it does have is a very poor forum.
N/A
It would be nice to publicize our meetings but Ryan has made it so that you need his permission or Bethany's to publish anything beyond a commented response to a post to the website. So the blame for lack of publication kind of lies with him. Ryan has taken heat because of his actions and, in more cases, his inaction. Any heat he's received is through his fault alone. Like has been said, if there is a majority that exists that supports Ryan, then everyone has yet to see them.
On a side note, we never really moved over to freenode; everyone just stayed on crash's server since there wasn't any good reason to move to freenode to begin with.
You need his permission to publicize meetings?!
I can not, for the life of me, think of one organization that doesn't make their meeting discussions available for members and the public. Well, maybe not the exact transcript, but at least an outline of things discussed.
In fact, some organizations actually take everything discussed at those weekly and/or monthly meetings and publish them with added details, pictures, and contact information in something called an eNewsletter!
Oh no, i've said to much.
Quick! Delete my comment before the masses learn of our ability to inform them of events through our electronic movable type!
cronies?
"If he had been Banned the moment he began his Downpour of stupid bull**** this would not have happened. "
If I had been banned the minute I started voicing my opinion, that would have been against the rules of the party. It would have been against the spirit of the party. Although I'm not sure your statement is logically true. I'm not alone in how I feel about the job Ryan has done - that's why the last two votes were unanimous.
It's funny you use a term like Cronies as well. I presume you mean the, how did you put it? ah yes "bunch of Jackasses" that is the membership. Of course, lets not forget that you are, by your own admission, one of Ryan's "cronies." Let me repeat a statement of yours from the middle of October
"Ryan Martin has won the Pirate party Administrative Officer Elections, meaning he just gained control of a US political Party. this was something we had been involved with on the side for several months, ryan had be casually assessing the party via their beloved social medium, IRC, it didn't take long before he had realized they were all a bunch of Jackasses. so he decided he could do it better. and we did, electing Ryan, as well as one of our online peers Bethany Jolly."
You admit that you were friends with Ryan beforehand, as was Bethany (now his girlfriend) and you were such good friends, that you went on this 'tour' with him. That is all by your own admission. If there is any 'crony' here, it would be you, sir.
andrew norton's divisive agenda
Andrew the votes weren't exactly unanimous or representative of all the pirates in the US - it was made up of seven or eight non-officers in meetings that were not openly advertised - furthermore in previous votes it was clear that people WERE expressing disapproval of your attempts to pass votes of no confidence (soylent bomb for one) and because of your personal vendettas have decided not to be a part of the party.
To put it bluntly - Andrew, your involvement in dividing the party and turning people against each other have proven absolutely destructive to the movement in the US, and you need to learn to be more humble and proactive in solving the problems facing the party instead of pushing forward your own personal agenda.
Then talk to me
Could you come on IRC, then? I'd like to talk to someone, if Ryan doesn't want to.